The frankensteins are a rich, influential family from geneva switzerland. Though all the frankenstein s believe she is innocent, only victor knows that the monster is the true murderer. The creature also kills frankensteins best friend, henry clerval, and the familys housekeeper, justine moritz. However, as elizabeth tells victor in a letter, a servant in geneva does not mean the.
In chapter 16, the monster is the victim of an injustice again. Shelley started writing the story when she was 18, and the first edition was published anonymously in london on 1 january 1818, when she was 20. Justines role and fate in frankenstein, did you associate her name with justice. Frankenstein chapters 58 summary and analysis gradesaver. In mary shelleys frankenstein, the character of justine moritz appears briefly, but. He cries out that he is a murderer, and begs his attendants to. My passionate and indignant appeals were lost upon them. Elizabeth fills many roles in frankensteins life, so when the monster kills her, frankenstein is deprived of almost every form of female companionship at once. Justine assumed an air of cheerfulness, while she with difficulty repressed her bitter tears. When frankenstein refuses, the monster says that he will then make it his lifes work to make his creator miserable. Justine is extremely religious, even after all that has happened to her. For two months, victor lies in a delirium of fever and confusion. He wanted to try to renew life in a corpse, to bestow animation upon lifeless matter. If williams death symbolizes the loss of innocence, justines death marks the end of all that is noble and righteous.
In addition to the people he actually murders, the monster ends up indirectly causing the death of a few. His travels carry him near geneva, where he meets william frankenstein, victors youngest brother. Shelley started writing the story when she was 18, and the first edition was published anonymously. Although she is innocent, she still confesses to the murder of william so that she will be forgiven for her. Justine constructed similarly to elizabeth and mrs frankenstein. Justine moritz became a servant for the frankenstein family at a young age, and became quite close to the family, particularly elizabeth. After confronting victor, the townspeople take him to mr.
Accused of williams murder, justine is the stolid martyr who goes to her death with grace and dignity. Why did the creature put the locket in justines dress. Victor hears witnesses testify against him, claiming that they found the body of a man along the beach the previous night and that, just before finding the body, they saw a boat in the water that resembled victors. The monster killed justines brother, william, because of his relation to victor frankenstein, whom he wants revenge against for creating such a horrible wretch such as himself. Victor proclaims justines innocence, but the evidence against her seems irrefutable, and victor refuses to explain himself for fear that he will be labeled insane. Her impassive countenance recalls that of a fragile doll. Justines death shows just how diabolical the monster has become. Justine was blamed for the death of williamvictors brother and sentenced to death.
Full of remorse, victor heads off into the mountains where he runs into the monster, who makes him listen to a long sob story. In justines defense, elizabeth tells the court of justines character and how she doted on young william and the frankenstein family. Mary shelleys frankenstein soundtrack 16 death of justine andrea navarro. The theme of justice in frankenstein essay 942 words. Elizabeth implores victor to write, and to visit, as both she and his father miss him terribly. Frankenstein is seized by an attack of conscience and resolves to write to them immediately. Before her death, how does justine spend her final moment with elizabeth. Justine moritz, ernest frankenstein, and william frankenstein. Elizabeths heartrending eloquence failed to move the judges from their settled conviction in the criminality of the saintly sufferer. Mary shelleys frankenstein soundtrack 16 death of justine.
Elizabeth is frankensteins adopted sister and his wife. Refer closely to the creation scene and justine s trial scene. We do not learn much about her character except that she embodies the best in suffering for a just cause. A servant in geneva does not mean the same thing as a servant in france and england. William frankenstein was murdered by being strangled to death by the monster that victor frankenstien created. The monsters final request from victor is to create him a mate.
Frankenstein throws himself upon the body, and becomes almost mad with grief and guilt. The minute attention paid to justines appearance, history, and speech only serves to heighten the sympathy felt by the reader. In fact, the name justine is probably word play on justice. When william is murdered, the monster puts a photograph that william was carrying in her pocket, and she is accused of murder. How important is the theme of justice in frankenstein. Victor proclaims justines innocence, but the evidence against her seems irrefutable, and victor refuses to explain himself for. Study guide questions frankenstein flashcards quizlet. How did frankenstein react when his experiment succeeded. Justine only appears briefly, but makes a strong impression, not only on the reader, but on the two main characters who are either directly or indirectly responsible for her death. Justines death illustrates the true nature of victor frankensteins enemy, the monster he created. The chapter is a commentary on mary shelley s view of the justice system. Anyway, elizabeth is catching up victor about what is going in the household which includes justine as a servant around the house.
In frankenstein, justine provides a part in the story that symbolizes some of the thinking of the time. He tells himself and us that the whole thing was to satisfy inexorable fatebut to us, it sounds more like hes just coming up with excuse after excuse. Throughout chapter 8, the sentences are confused, and semicolons are. Justine moritz the housekeeper for the frankenstein family. Asked in science fiction, frankenstein was victor frankenstein guilty of the murder of justine and william and what historical event proves that. The creature threatens victor that he will be with him on his wedding. In mary shelleys 1818 version of frankenstein, justine moritz, ernest frankenstein, and william frankenstein play relatively small, but important, roles. Justine moritz is a minor character who is of major importance in mary shelleys frankenstein. After the discovery of the body, a servant had found in justines pocket a picture of caroline frankenstein last seen in williams possession. Apr 22, 2015 what did elizabeth say about justine in her letter to victor. As the trial had proceeded, her countenance had altered. Elizabeth relates how she came to join the frankenstein household. The patriarch, meaning the powerful father of the family, is named alphonse, and the mother, who.
The monster frames justine for the murder of victors youngest brother, william, a murder the. What do we learn from the creatures tale about how william died. Justine is well treated by the frankenstein family and is regarded not as household help, but with the. Victor is now suffering living torture for the consequences of his actions since his university days. The next day, however, when he returns home, victor learns that justine has been accused of the murder.
It sounds crazy, so he doesnt tell anyoneeven when the frankenstein family servant, justine moritz, is wrongly executed for the crime. She represents graceful suffering in the face of injustice, much like a martyr. Realizing who the boy is, the monster murders the child and plants the locket in justines dress pocket. I was soon introduced into the presence of the magistrate, an old benevolent man with calm and mild manners. Victor frankenstein is the main character in mary shelleys 1818 novel frankenstein. He cries out that he is a murderer, and begs his attendants to aid him in apprehending the monster. In mary shelleys 1818 version of frankenstein, justine moritz, ernest. The creature also kills frankenstein s best friend, henry clerval, and the familys housekeeper, justine moritz. Justine moritz, ernest frankenstein, and william frankenstein mary. The minute attention paid to justine s appearance, history, and speech only serves to heighten the sympathy felt by the reader. Learn vocabulary, terms, and more with flashcards, games, and other study tools.
Listening to the men in her group talk about scientific experiments e. He feels in some ways that justines murder is the worse of the two he is responsible for the other far more dreadfully murdered 57 and later, while sick and incarcerated in ireland, calls himself the murderer of william. How did the monster from frankenstein kill justine answers. How did the author get the idea for the novel frankenstein. Frankenstein is seized by an attack of conscience and resolves to write to. I really wanted to point a parallel similarity between elizabeth and justine. What victor fears is that the female monster, were she to be created, would have autonomy. Justine proclaims her innocence, she is convicted of the crime. Victor does not believe she is guilty, and neither will elizabeth, despite any. Discussion questions for frankenstein written by hailey toporcer, hiram college class of 2019 edited by prof. In frankenstein, how does the creature cause the deaths of. A young woman who the frankensteins adopt at the age of 12. Her beauty, too, both transports him to ecstasy and fills him with bitter despair, since he will never know the pleasures of love. What did the creature do when the girl fell in the water.
Justice is defined as justice is the administration of law. In addition to the people he actually murders, the monster. There is no doubt in the mind of the reader that justine and william are innocent. Full of remorse, victor heads off into the mountains where he runs into the monster, who makes him listen to a long sob story about how mommywe mean, victorhas ruined his life. Justine, in mary shelleys novel frankenstein, initially sates that she is innocent of the murder of william. Justine is the housekeeper for the frankenstein family. We stayed several hours with justine, and it was with great difficulty that elizabeth could tear herself away. Mary shelleys 1818 classic, frankenstein, gave to the world of literature some truly memorable characters. The monster strangles william to death, takes the picture of his mother from his possession, and plants it in justines pocket while she takes a rest and sleeps in a. Surprise, horror, and misery were strongly expressed.
Servant to the frankenstein family and particular friend of elizabeth. Elizabeth, the beloved friend and, later, fiancee of victor frankenstein, is murdered by the creature victor has made. Frankenstein has just told us that justine was executed, and, well, he seems to be going a little crazy. They were both adopted in the frankenstein household. When victor repeats his assertion of justines innocence, her father remarks, she is to be tried today, and i hope, i sincerely hope, that she will be acquitted. She is convicted of the murder of william frankenstein on circumstantial evidence and executed. Why did the creature frame the woman justine for the murder. May 29, 2015 a servant in geneva does not mean the same thing as a servant in france and england. Mar, 2015 frankenstein throws himself upon the body, and becomes almost mad with grief and guilt. Justine, described as a girl of merit shelley, 57, embodies goodness of character and serves as. Justine, thus received in our family, learned the duties of a servant, a condition which, in our fortunate country, does not include the idea of ignorance and a sacrifice of the dignity of a human being. Justine is already a martyr, in the frankenstein familys eyes, in that she is willing to suffer the guilt for a crime she did not commit. Refer closely to the creation scene and justines trial scene. He is an italianswiss scientist born in naples, italy who, after studying chemical processes and the decay of living beings, gains an insight into the creation of life and gives life to his own creature, often referred to as frankenstein s monster, or often colloquially referred to.
She confesses falsely to the crime out of fear of going to hell. Elizabeth and victor go to see justine in prison where both learn that justine had given a false confession under stiff questioning. Justine is well treated by the frankenstein family and is regarded not as household help, but with the esteem and affection accorded a family member. Kirsten parkinson as you read mary shelleys frankenstein, either on your own or with a group, we invite you to use these questions to add layers to your discussion or thinking about the novel. Victor frankenstein feels tremendously guilty over justines death, and tortures himself endlessly over it. Dec, 2012 seeking a hiding place, he enters a nearby barn and finds justine sleeping within. Kirwin decides to bring victor to look at the body to see what. What did the creature tell frankenstein about the locket. Justine, however, was charged for the murder because they found williams locket in. Jun 28, 2012 mary shelleys frankenstein soundtrack 16 death of justine andrea navarro.
414 394 1032 921 1194 815 795 1263 1221 255 1247 360 4 1549 1046 406 1380 793 430 1370 443 857 1665 9 1663 945 1667 524 1552 1303 1319 598 701 1348 672 1422 1153 1177 952 1123 215 776 943 1398